(Mike Pettinella/contributed to this story with interviews and photos)
The former JCPenney property was sold at auction on Thursday morning at the Genesee County Courts Facility.
Reporter Mike Pettinella says Matt Gray, and his partner Matt Boyd, who are partners at Eli Fish Brewery, bid $175K to win the auction.
Bill Baskin of Baskin Livestock, Creek Road in the Town of Batavia, was the only other bidder during the auction.
Attorney and former state senator Michael Ranzenhofer was appointed by the court to officiate the auction and went over the terms pertaining to the winning bidder. Bidding opened at $1,000. (File photo)

Gray went back and forth bidding with the bank, Twenty Lake Holdings, until Bill Baskin’s bid of $102,000. Gray responded with a bid of $125,000. Baskin then came back with a bid of $150,000. Gray then placed a bid of $175,000. No one else matched the bid.


(Photos/Mike Pettinella)
After the auction, Matt Gray would not say what his plans are for the building which is 38,524 square feet.
” I think you know what I like, I like a vibrant downtown, I like city living, I love residential above our commercial, but as far as this building goes, it’s been a vacant hole in our downtown and it needs to have something there, so it’s just a way of moving the ball forward. I’m excited,” said Gray.
The property at 40 City Centre is zoned commercial has been vacant since 2020 after JCPenney closed. It was purchased in 2021 for $500,000 by Yong Guang Ye of California but was foreclosed on with a lien of $179,141 attached to the property along with back taxes, school taxes and back water bills.

City Manager Rachael Tabelski was on hand for the auction as well as Batavia Development Corporation (BDC) Director of Economic Development Tammy Hathaway. Both were excited about moving forward.
“We’re very excited about getting this property into the hands of a local businessman. We look forward to working with him on his plans and bringing any resources that the state, county and city can bear to redevelop the property. Whether that becomes housing, we’ll have to find out his plans. We definitely think this is an anchor parcel in City Centre and downtown,” said Tabelski.
Tabelski says she did not know Gray was going to be at the auction today.
“Knowing his project history and his success in business, he was the first person in the City of Batavia to use historic tax credits on the Newberry building and how he was able to transform that space into a community gathering space and restaurant and his ownership of other restaurants, I think this a great day for Batavia, that building is now with someone local who has a vested interest in the community, he now runs our hockey rink its better than ever. I’m just extremely excited that he won this bid.”
In December, the City of Batavia held and open house looking for the public’s input on redevelopment sites around the City of Batavia. The JCPenney site was one of them. Tabelski says the commercial zoning requires the property to be retail, commercial housing oriented.
Link to Open House: BATAVIA/Open House held for residents to comment on the future development of the Tonawanda Creek waterfront near the ice rink – Video News Service
Hathaway says she is thankful someone local now has the building.
“It’s somebody that we know, it’s somebody that has experienced success in their endeavors with renovating and redeveloping areas of Batavia. So, it’s a trusted community member. We already have an established relationship with this individual,” says Hathaway.
We would like to see a big lots there