GENESEE COUNTY/Sheriff’s office, regional partners work together to thwart organized retail theft

Investigator Erik Andre, left, and Undersheriff Ryan DeLong with just a small number of the items confiscated by the Genesee County Sheriff’s Office in its crackdown on organized retail theft. Photo by Mike Pettinella/For Video News Service

BY MIKE PETTINELLA
For Video News Service

It takes hard work and plenty of collaboration, but the Genesee County Sheriff’s Office is taking a bite out of organized retail theft rings that cost New York State stores billions of dollars in annual revenue.

“Over the last year we’ve seen a dip in the numbers (of retail theft incidents) as we’ve definitely leveraged our relationships with the private sector – the stores and their asset protection or loss prevention personnel,” Undersheriff Ryan DeLong said on Friday afternoon.

DeLong and Criminal Investigator Erik Andre sat down with Video News Service to talk about the agency’s push to crack down on organized retail theft.

Much of the theft occurs from the big-box stores along Veterans Memorial Drive, DeLong said, providing statistics that show the number of calls responded to by the sheriff’s office from those stores has decreased from 134 in 2023 to 124 in 2024 and 74 through November of this year.

He said his office has “created an environment” where store asset protection and/or loss prevention personnel are communicating with each other and with law enforcement on a daily basis.

“If one loss prevention person sees something, they talk to the other stores, which helps us (in attempting to locate the perpetrators),” he said. “We have established a really good relationship with them where they call us right away and Erik can speak to some instances where we have notified stores that property is being stolen from them without their knowledge.”

TAKING A PROACTIVE APPROACH

Asked how investigators or deputies are able to do that, DeLong said it happens through different sources.

“It could be human intelligence or it could be open source intelligence,” he said. “We’ve actually discovered an individual, for example, who walked out with multiple power tools. We discovered this. We, in turn, went back to the store and asked them to check their inventory and their cameras sure enough — based on the descriptors, the date and time we give them, they say, yes, we observe someone on camera walking out with those exact items you mentioned.

“Then, obviously, we ask them would you like to pursue criminal charges against that person. We’ve kind of taken a proactive approach to retail as opposed to just being reactive.”

New York State Police also are taken a proactive stance on organized retail theft with the creation of a task force that, according to Gov. Hochul’s office, has recovered more than $2.6 million in stolen goods statewide since April 2024.

In a press release last month, Hochul stated that State Police and local law enforcement have made 1,224 arrested and filed 2,146 charges – resulting in a 13 percent decrease in larceny outside of New York City from January through June of this year as compared to the same time last year.

“Following the pandemic, New York’s retailers faced a sharp surge in organized retail theft, which is why we invested in law enforcement and strengthened our laws to hold perpetrators accountable, protect workers and support the small business owners who are the backbone of our economy,” Hochul said. “Thanks to the work of the State Police Organized Retail Theft Task Force, our partners in local law enforcement and district attorneys across the state, we are recovering more stolen goods, making more arrests and seeing positive results.”

DeLong said his office is not a member of that task force but noted that Genesee County works regularly with State Police investigators and troopers.

WORKING WELL WITH REGIONAL PARTNERS

“Law enforcement as a whole has just been very cognizant of organized retail crime and it is a priority,” he said. “We work well with all of our regional partners — utilizing the resources of our fusion centers which are intel agencies in Monroe County, Erie County and Niagara County. In each one of those places they have law enforcement officers from various agencies as well.”

Video News Service reached out to Trooper James O’Callaghan, Troop A public information officer, to participate in this story but did not hear back from him.

DeLong said the Christmas season usually means a spike in retail theft but that hasn’t been the case this year.

“I think that’s a credit to our law enforcement partners and our deputy sheriffs,” he said. “We’re proactive. When they (deputies) make pass-bys through the plazas – we call it visual compliance – they’re doing paperwork and park their cars in visible areas as a deterrent.”

When asked about the difficulty of apprehending suspects with the New York State Thruway close by, DeLong noted the “close proximity” of both the sheriff’s office and the troopers’ barracks.

“Many times we at least get a description of the vehicle, maybe the last few digits of a plate, and we have systems where we can run some checks and narrow that down,” he said.

The undersheriff said that law enforcement pursuits – high-speed chases – do occur.

“We had one about a month ago that actually went down the Thruway, then they got off at Pembroke, looped back around and back on the Thruway, with the pursuit actually ending in Erie County,” he said.

METHOD TO THEIR MADNESS

Andre said that these crooks work as a team – one person running into the store to grab the product, someone to distract the store employee, a lookout in the parking lot and a driver to speed up the getaway time.

“When talking about organized retail theft, you’re looking at a crew of a few people that typically will target one type of store,” he said. “So, they’ll hit that exact big box store in multiple counties because they know how to steal from that particular store.

“Over a period of time, it could be weeks, they’ll hit Monroe County, and then a couple days later, they’ll hit our locations here and they they’ll go up to Erie County. We’ve had some go across the state, targeting that specific store.”

The investigator said crime ring members take note of law enforcement response times and share that information with other potential thieves.

“That’s another part of our numbers going down,” he said. “These organizations will talk. Some may avoid this county because the response time is so quick, and they’ve been apprehended so quickly, while in other larger counties, the response time is slow, and they’re getting away with more product and not facing criminal charges.”

Andre said those who steal know where to unload the merchandise to make a profit or they’re selling it to third parties.

BOGUS BILLS ARE PART OF THE SCHEME

DeLong mentioned another part of the retail theft equation – using counterfeit bills to purchase merchandise.

“It’s not only just the theft of the products, when you look at organized retail crime, it’s also cases that we’ve had where people are using fraudulent money to purchase products and then returning them to a separate store because then they’re getting tangible, real cash back,” he said. “We’ve seen that across the Northeast and even into the Midwest — the same people doing that.

“I’ve even had a case where an individual was purchasing video games. And they had the tools to reseal the game so that it looked like it wasn’t ever opened. So, then they’re returning the games.”

Andre said some thieves have devices to remove the electronic sensors placed on products, notably clothes, so they can leave the store without triggering the alarm.

Asked about the percentage of those arrested who are convicted of a crime, DeLong said he didn’t know for sure but credited the district attorney’s office for also making organized retail theft a priority.

“With anything, there are probably some plea deals that are made in some cases and pleading to the charge in other cases,” he said. “I can certainly say that they’re always receptive to our phone calls and they work very well with us when it comes to us charging and then prosecuting. They’ve been a very good partner for us.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *