GENESEE COUNTY/Batavia Players announce nominees for the 2025 Harvie Awards

Batavia, NY — Batavia Players is proud to announce the nominees for the 2025 Harvie Awards, honoring outstanding performances and creative achievement from the organization’s 2025 season of plays, musicals, cabarets, and staged mysteries presented at Main St. 56 Theater.

The Harvie Awards celebrate excellence onstage and behind the scenes, recognizing the artists, designers, performers, and youth participants who brought imagination, talent, and heart to the Batavia Players’ 2025 season.

2025 Eligible Productions

Plays
The Mousetrap • The Winter’s Tale • Waiting for Godot

Musicals
Jesus Christ Superstar • Frozen Jr. • Be More Chill • It’s A Wonderful Life

Cabarets
Cupid’s Stupid: A Valentine’s Day Cabaret • Lights, Camera, Action! • Laugh Tracks

Staged Mysteries
Murder at the Café on the Corner • Murder at the Carnival • Murder at the Library

Performance Nominations Highlights

Nominees span a wide range of categories including Outstanding Lead, Supporting, and Featured Performances in plays and musicals, as well as Cabaret and Staged Mystery performances, Solo Musical Performances, Ensemble Numbers, and Youth and Child Performances.

This year’s nominations reflect the depth of talent across all age groups, with strong representation from seasoned performers, rising young artists, and first-time nominees alike.


Design & Creative Achievement

The 2025 Harvie Awards also recognize excellence in production design and choreography, with nominations for:

  • Outstanding Choreography
  • Outstanding Design of a Play
  • Outstanding Design of a Musical
  • Outstanding Design of a Cabaret or Staged Mystery

These categories highlight the collaborative artistry that brings each production to life — from lighting and costumes to sound, set, and movement.


Celebrating Community Theatre

“The Harvie Awards are about more than trophies,” said Patrick Burk, President of Batavia Players. “They’re about celebrating the incredible creativity, commitment, and community spirit that make live theatre thrive in Batavia. This year’s nominees truly reflect the bold, imaginative, and heartfelt work happening on our stage.”

Winners will be announced at the 2026 Harvie Awards Gala, where Batavia Players will gather to celebrate another unforgettable season of community theatre.

GALA HARVIE CATAGORIES
2025 PLAYS
The Mousetrap – The Winter’s Tale – Waiting For Godot
2025 MUSICALS
Jesus Christ, Superstar – Frozen Junior – Be More Chill – It’s A Wonderful Life
2025 CABARETS
Cupid’s Stupid: A Valentine’s Day Cabaret – Lights, Camera, Action! – Laugh Tracks
2025 MYSTERIES
Murder at the Café on the Corner – Murder at the Carnival – Murder at the Library

Outstanding Lead Male Actor in a Play
Anthony Haitz – The Winter’s Tale
Richard Ferris – Waiting for Godot
Steven Coburn – Waiting for Godot
Elijah Van Epps – The Mousetrap
Outstanding Lead Female Actor in a Play
Dorothy Gerhart – The Winter’s Tale
Leigh LeFevre – The Mousetrap
Sophie Houseman – The Winter’s Tale
Outstanding Supporting Male Actor in a Play
Richard Ferris – The Winter’s Tale
James Barcomb – Waiting for Godot
Mark Anderson – The Mousetrap
James Franklin – The Mousetrap
Outstanding Supporting Female Actor in a Play
Samantha Scheffler-Ploetz – The Winter’s Tale
Mollie Wadhams – The Mousetrap
Lily Kasprzyk – The Winter’s Tale
Outstanding Featured Male Actor in a Play
Kevin Partridge – The Winter’s Tale
James Barcomb – The Mousetrap
James Franklin – Waiting for Godot
Anthony Haitz – The Mousetrap
Outstanding Featured Female Actor in a Play
Amelia Schuster – The Mousetrap
Teressa Hirsch – The Winter’s Tale
Lilah Mordell – The Winter’s Tale
Celeste Vescovi – The Winter’s Tale
Outstanding Lead Male Actor in a Musical
Elijah Van Epps – Jesus Christ Superstar
Ian Cannioto – Jesus Christ Superstar
Xander Gonzalez – Be More Chill
Adam Tabelski – It’s A Wonderful Life
Outstanding Lead Female Actor in a Musical
Erin Stamp – Jesus Christ Superstar
Amelia Schuster – It’s A Wonderful Life
Lilah Mordell – Be More Chill
Elle Williams – Frozen Junior
Outstanding Supporting Male Actor in a Musical
William Zerillo – Be More Chill
James Franklin – It’s A Wonderful Life
Matt Stevens – Jesus Christ, Superstar
Anthony Haitz – Jesus Christ Superstar
Outstanding Supporting Female Actor in a Musical
Erin Stamp – It’s A Wonderful Life
Sophie Houseman – Jesus Christ Superstar
Maia Zerillo – Be More Chill
Amora Mabon – Be More Chill
Outstanding Featured Male Actor in a Musical
Seth Coburn – Be More Chill
Deacon Smith – Jesus Christ Superstar
Bill Moon – It’s A Wonderful Life
Elijah Saile – Be More Chill
Outstanding Featured Female Actor in a Musical
Amanda Melissa Taylor – Jesus Christ Superstar
Lyla Jones – Be More Chill
Trish Miller – It’s A Wonderful Life
Jessica Brandt – It’s A Wonderful Life
Outstanding Male Performance in a Cabaret
Stephen Efing VanValkenburg – Lights Camera Action
James Barcomb – Laugh Tracks
Skylar Dence – Lights Camera Action
Deacon Smith – Laugh Tracks
Outstanding Female Performance in a Cabaret
Sophie Houseman – Lights Camera Action
Sarah Hill – Cupid’s Stupid
Mollie Wadhams – Laugh Tracks
Mia Pellegrino – Cupid’s Stupid
Outstanding Male Performance in a Staged Mystery
Seth Coburn – Murder at the Library
James Barcomb – Murder at the Café on the Corner
Skylar Dence – Murder at the Carnival
Anthony Haitz – Murder at the Library
Outstanding Female Performance in a Staged Mystery
Tess Uline – Murder at the Library
Kaitlyn Sheinhartz – Murder at the Café on the Corner
Sarah Hill- Murder at the Carnival
Mollie Wadhams – Murder at the Carnival
Outstanding Male Solo Musical Performance in a Musical or Cabaret
Patrick Burk – Raindrops Keep Falling On My Head – Lights Camera Action
Ian Cannioto –Heaven on Their Minds– Jesus Christ Superstar
Elijah Van Epps – Gethsemane – Jesus Christ Superstar
Deacon Smith – Schadenfreude – Laugh Tracks
Xander Gonzalez – Loser Geek Whatever – Be More Chill
Outstanding Female Solo Musical Performance in a Musical or Cabaret
Sarah Hill – You Don’t Know This Man – Cupid’s Stupid
Erin Stamp – I Don’t Know How to Love Him – Jesus Christ Superstar
Sophie Houseman – Skyfall – Lights Camera Action
Mia Pelligrino – Because I Liked A Boy – Cupid’s Stupid
Amora Mabon – Pitiful Children – Be More Chill
Outstanding Ensemble Musical Performance in a Musical or Cabaret
Superstar – Jesus Christ Superstar
From Now On – Lights Camera Action
Do We Shock You – Laugh Tracks
Falling Slowly – Cupid’s Stupid
More Than Survive – Be More Chill
Outstanding Youth Performance (18 & Under)
William Zerillo – Be More Chill
Lilah Mordell – Laugh Tracks
Amora Mabon – Be More Chill
Elijah Saile – Be More Chill
Outstanding Child Performance (12 & Under)
Liam Taylor – It’s A Wonderful Life
Axton Engler – Frozen Junior
Charlotte Redden – Frozen Junior
Elle Williams – Frozen Junior
Outstanding Choreography
Be More Chill
Lights Camera Action
Laugh Tracks
Cupid’s Stupid
Outstanding Design of a Play
The Winter’s Tale
The Mousetrap
Waiting for Godot
Outstanding Design of a Musical
Jesus Christ Superstar
Be More Chill
Frozen Junior
It’s A Wonderful Life
Outstanding Design of a Cabaret or Staged Mystery
Laugh Tracks
Murder at the Carnival
Lights Camera Action
Cupid’s Stupid

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *