
BY MIKE PETTINELLA
For Video News Service
Genesee County Supreme Court Justice Diane Y. Devlin on Thursday ordered Stafford property owner James Pontillo to pay $2,285.76 for missing a Sept. 15 deadline to complete court-ordered repairs at the former Stafford Trading Post building at 6177 Main St. Rd.
In granting the motion brought by the town and signed by her on Feb. 11, Judge Devlin did not consider Pontillo’s claims that extenuating circumstances – primarily vehicles parked by Shell’s Post employees and/or patrons next to the west side of his structure – prevented him from completing the work on time.
“Based on this simple thing (the negotiated agreement that set the Sept. 15 deadline), I grant the motion,” Devlin said after hearing arguments from town attorney David Roach of DiMatteo Roach & Kelly of Warsaw and Pontillo.
The judge did, however, waive the 9 percent interest provision in the notice of motion, saving Pontillo an additional $67 or so. She said interest charges would accrue beginning on Friday if the fine isn’t paid by then.

(File photo)
The motion stemmed from action taken by the town – and approved by the court – to force Pontillo to address a list of 18 items in need of repair on the exterior of the building at the corner of Routes 5 and 237.
Town officials declared that the mandated work was needed to bring the exterior into compliance with the New York Property Maintenance Code, sections 108, 304, 305 and National Electric Code, section 300, both codified in the New York State Uniform Fire Prevention and Building Code.
Speaking first, Roach cited the notice of motion, stating that Pontillo would be subject to a fine of $1,000 per week – or $142.86 per day – if he failed to complete the work on time.
“There is no dispute that he was late,” Roach said, adding that Town Code Enforcement Officer Gene Sinclair signed off on an Oct. 2 completion date.
As a result, the fine amounted to $2,285.76.
“That’s all we’re seeking here, Roach said. “We’re not looking outside the terms … it’s simple math.”
Roach mentioned that Pontillo would be bringing up excuses – “neighbors parked on the property,” but added that “there was no reason to look outside of the order.”
The lawyer said the parties agreed to the Sept. 15 date on Feb. 2, giving Pontillo seven months to finish, but that Pontillo didn’t start until late June. He also noted that the property maintenance code allows for a fine of $1,000 per day and the town could have gone back years, where the fine would have grown into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Roach called the $142.86 per day fine “a concession that the town took to get this done.”
Judge Devlin then asked Pontillo to speak, advising him to stick to the matter at hand.

(File photo)
Pontillo contended that starting the work in June provided him with “ample time” but vandalism and the intentional parking of vehicles along the border of his property by people at Shell’s Post caused him to miss the deadline.
He said he contacted law enforcement personnel, who suggested him putting up a temporary fence, which he did. He said he installed cameras and put up extra signage and cones, which put an end to the vandalism.


(File photos-summer 2025)
When vehicles blocked his equipment on the west side (where he was putting up siding), he said he had to rent a lift, costing him $1,700 and that caused further delays. He said he asked for additional time from the town, but to no avail.
With vehicles blocking access, Pontillo said it took him three weeks to do that west side while it took five weeks for the other three sides combined.
“I tried to make arrangements with Mr. Roach and the town for a settlement but there was no effort to do that,” he said. “So, we’re here today.”
Pontillo went on to blame Mitch Bryan, Shell’s Post manager, for making things difficult.
“Mitch filed the complaint (to get the repairs done) and (now) he’s stopping me from doing the work,” Pontillo said. “And the work (we did) was above what was required.”
Roach then stated that Pontillo should have started the work in March or April. Pontillo countered by saying that he moved four other construction projects up and initially had asked for an Oct. 15 completion date.
Pontillo said he had to pay $1,500 in fines to get the September date while the town wanted $10,000 for him to start in October.
In the end, Judge Devlin pointed out that this was a “negotiated” agreement and, while acknowledging that Pontillo had other “irons in the fire,” he didn’t get the work done on time.