
Pontillo speaking to the board on Monday evening
By Mike Pettinella
For Video News Service
James Pontillo, citing “frustration” with the Stafford Town Board, says he plans to run for the town supervisor position that is up for reelection in 2027, looking to replace longtime Supervisor Robert Clement.
Pontillo made his intentions known, albeit informally, at the outset of Monday night’s Town Board meeting, following a discussion about the unsightly condition of a resident’s property.
Link to meeting: GENESEE COUNTY/Stafford Town Board Meeting/March 9, 2026 – Video News Service
Several in attendance, including Pontillo – the owner of the former Stafford Trading Post building who had been involved in litigation with the town for over a decade – asked the board to hold off on paying attorney’s fees and to give citizens the opportunity to help the resident clean up their property.
After Board Member Terry Young said he didn’t think it was a waste to use a lawyer to force a resident to clean up their property, Pontillo said, “Don’t you think it was a waste spending fifty, eighty thousand dollars litigating me for over 10 years?”
Young responded by saying, “It wasn’t a waste. Something got done.”

Pontillo at the March 9th, 2026 Stafford Town Board meeting announces he is running for Town Supervisor in 2027
That was enough for Pontillo, who replied, “You know what? I’m going to make an announcement now because I can see that we’re not going to get anywhere. I’m going to go ahead and put my hat in; I’m going to run for town supervisor, okay?”
“I will be successful, and I’m going to go ahead and predict that Clement will step down before that happens. And you’ll (directing his comments to Deputy Supervisor Ronald Panek) probably contact your wife over at the Republican Party and try to sit in that position thinking you’ll have a better chance.
“I believe this community is done being bled and you all just seem to be clueless as to the concerns of this community. And you’re not willing to stand behind this community.”
After a board member responded with “you’re so wrong, Jim,” Pontillo said, “No, I’m not,” prompting others in attendance to loudly agree with him.

Stafford Town Board at Monday’s meeting
Young shot back, stating, “I’m not here to argue with you. That’s your opinion. You can run for whatever you want to run for. But don’t degrade me as a person.”
Pontillo then replied, “I’m not degrading you. You guys have lost focus.”
Contacted on Tuesday afternoon, Pontillo said that he and others previously reached out to the board and said they would help clean up the property targeted for code violations that is located across from the town hall.
“I’m running (for supervisor) out of frustration with this board and will contact the election office to start the process,” Pontillo said. “What I and others have observed for far too long is the board’s lack of connection to the community and no transparency. There’s no litigation with me anymore; no gag order, so I intend to speak out.”