
(File photo)
By Mike Pettinella
For Video News Service
An order signed on Feb. 11 by Genesee County Supreme Court Judge Diane Y. Devlin gives James Pontillo until midnight on Sept. 15 of this year to address a list of 18 items in need of repair at the former Odd Fellows Hall and Stafford Trading Post at 6177 Main St. Rd., Stafford.
Should Pontillo fail to complete the work stipulated in the order by that date, he would be subject to fines of $1,000 per week.
The order, which was obtained by Video News Service, formalizes an agreement reached by Pontillo, who was represented by attorney Chad Hummel of Rochester, and the Town of Stafford, which was represented by David Roach, lawyer with DiMatteo Roach & Kelly of Warsaw.
It, conceivably, ends a years’ long battle between Pontillo and the town over the condition of the historic building.

(File photo)
Roach, contacted on Thursday, said it’s up to Pontillo to live up to the agreement by bringing the exterior of the structure into compliance with the New York Property Maintenance Code, sections 108, 304, 305 and National Electric Code, section 300, both codified in the New York State Uniform Fire Prevention and Building Code.
“I hope he gets it done. The Town very much wants to see him comply with the court order that he’s obligated under,” he said.

(File photo)
Pontillo, contacted on Friday, said he paid for and received building permits from the Town of Stafford code enforcement officer and is prepared to tackle the list of repairs outlined under Exhibit A of the court order.
“We’re looking to, obviously, we’re going to be siding the three sides (of the building), we’re going to address the front, we’re going to re-stain the deck and doing some alterations to the deck as per the code,” he said.
“On the back side, there’s an old deck that’s getting removed and we’re going to be putting two steps there. So, basically, we’re taking care of the outside to meet the code because it’s a vacant building.”

(File photo)
Specifically, the 18 items on the “punch list” identified by the Town of Stafford — and then looked into by architect Matthew Hume on behalf of Pontillo – are as follows:
— Replace 11 support columns in the basement and certify the building is structurally sound. (Hume, in a separate letter to Pontillo, stated that he conducted a visual inspection of the columns and that “these wood columns and their footings are of sufficient size and integrity to support the current loads from the first floor and they are not in any immediate danger of falling).
— Replace exterior siding with long-term weather protection.
— Replace rotted exterior wood boards.
— Replace missing wood shingles and trim; scrape and paint all exterior walls.
— Properly replace the exterior landing for the first floor door on the north side of the building.
— Permanently fix or wall off second story egress door and refurbish or replace the first floor doors on the north side of the building.
— Install missing soffits.
— Fix leaks in roof.
— Replace boarded and broken windows.
— Remove electric meter box on east side of building; attach new meter box to west side of building.
— Fill in hole at the bottom of the foundation wall.
— Remove broken concrete on north side of the building.
— Fix foundation walls.
— Restore the rusty awning.
— Repair steps on west end of front platform.
— Apply protective sealant to the wood deck.
— Repair hole in upper area of south side of building.
— Repair and install fencing or remove the same on the west side of the building.

(File photo)
“It’s all cosmetic on the outside,” Pontillo added. “The only thing that actually required a permit were the two steps in the back. Plus, they gave me an extension on the roof permit that I already had.”
The court order also states that the town’s code enforcement officer has the right to inspect the building exterior for compliance “during daylight hours and with 24 hours’ notice to Pontillo.”
It also stated that any work not related to the Exhibit A items “shall require an additional building application and fee submitted to the town with accompanying plans stamped by a licensed engineer or licensed architect as required under the NYSUFPBC.”
Additionally, a fine was levied against Pontillo for “violations pursuant to the New York State Property Maintenance Code” but the amount was redacted from the court order, which requires all parties to refrain from disclosing the amount of the fine.
When asked if a fine was imposed, Roach replied, “No comment.”
Hummel, contacted on Friday, said that Pontillo is “looking forward to buttoning up all the issues that need to get resolved and only wants to move this thing forward.”
He then turned his focus onto the Stafford Town Board.
“As I said before, some of these (charges) were nitpicking type of things, but we finally came to terms with the town on what it was going to take to put this lawsuit to bed,” Hummel said. “The lawsuit was about declaring the property abandoned, and they were seeking a court order to actually seize the property and either demolish it or sell it.
“In my opinion, that was never going to happen. It was a non-starter lawsuit, but they brought it anyway. They used it as leverage to get some things out of Pontillo and, from that standpoint, it worked. In kind of a bully fashion, they were able to get some things out of him.
“But they were things that needed to be done anyway. They weren’t the types of things that should have been a Supreme Court lawsuit that cost the town and Mr. Pontillo a lot of wasted money; a lot of wasted money and time. James will move on. He’ll land on his feet and get this behind him.”
Ron Panek, deputy supervisor for the Town of Stafford, said he plans to bring the subject up at the next Town Board meeting at 7:30 p.m. April 14.
When asked for a statement, he said, “I think I’ll leave that until we have a board meeting. If we’re going to answer a question, we’re going to answer a question as a board.”
Pingback: GENESEE COUNTY/Stafford Town Board to consult attorney regarding Pontillo’s request to waive fine – Video News Service