
BY MIKE PETTINELLA
For Video News Service
James Pontillo received some support from a couple town residents on Monday night in his bid to have the Stafford Town Board waive the fine imposed him for missing the deadline to complete work on the former Stafford Trading Post building.
The board, however, did not commit to anything along those lines after engaging in a 20-plus minute back-and-forth with Pontillo during the monthly board meeting at the Stafford Town Hall.
James Pontillo states his case in front of the Stafford Town Board on Monday night. Photo by Mike Pettinella/For Video News Service.
Pontillo asked the board to drop the fine of $2,285.76 – based on $142.80 per day for the 16 days he failed to meet the court-ordered completion date of Sept. 15. He said circumstances beyond his control prevented him from finishing the work on time and he is prepared to state his case in court if necessary.
Two residents in the audience agreed with Pontillo that it is time to put this years-long dispute in the rear-view mirror.
“I think the townspeople would like to see it resolved,” said Donna Voorhees. “We’re tired of hearing it; we’re tired of the articles; we’re tired of reading all the comments and we’re tired of paying the lawyers. We’ve paid enough.”
Per information obtained from a recent budget work session, the town spent $8,129 in legal fees pertaining to the Pontillo matter in 2025.
Beth Carr accused the board of being “passive aggressive” with Pontillo, owner of the historic structure at the corner of Routes 5 and 237.
“It’s time to pick up everybody’s toys and go home,” she said.
Previously:
The issue came up early in the meeting when Supervisor Robert Clement read the code enforcement officer report written by Gene Sinclair, who stated the work was “substantially finished” and that a certificate of completion would be issued when the fines are paid.
Pontillo got his chance to speak at the end of the meeting.
“The way I see it, the board has two directions to go. One would have a situation for an amendment to the court order. What I mean by that is you would say he met the terms and it’s complete and it’s over with. And that would not include any fine,” he said.
“Otherwise, the town would have to bring a motion to address any claim that I violated the order. Then we would probably end up back in court, with the attorneys, and I would be able to present my case why it took longer, possibly subpoenaing individuals that I thought necessary to do that.”
Pontillo said he would send a “short list” of those people to David Roach, attorney representing the town in this matter, “and he would probably want to talk to them first, and want to know why I am bringing those (people) in. I really don’t see why that is necessary.”
The property owner also mentioned that he had to pay “a substantial amount of money to even reach an agreement so that we could come to the resolution that we have now.”
In short, Pontillo wants the board to write a letter to the court, stating that it is satisfied with the repairs and rescinding the fine.
Deputy Supervisor Ronald Panek said the board would talk to Roach but also said that waiving the fine could set a precedent and that it was Pontillo’s “responsibility to be compliant to the New York State Building Code.”
Pontillo countered that he is in compliance and that the board was “being petty and being resentful.”
Clement mentioned on a couple occasions that he was pleased with how Pontillo’s building looks today – stating that it was “a nice job” that “improved the building immensely.”
He also said that he hoped for a “positive” outcome, but was stopped by Panek, who cautioned against making a determination at that point.
When asked by Video News Service if the board had the authority to vote on waiving the fine, the answer was “yes.”
Clement said the board had no objection to the work that was done, prompting Pontillo to say, “The objection now is that there’s now another fine that wants to be levied on top of the money that I had to pay to get to this point.”
“I’m asking you all to meet with Mr. Roach, bring a resolution that we can just be done with this with no additional add-ons and everything else.”
A Resolution?? For 8 years we have had squatters on our property represented by Mr. Roach. Where is ourresoltion?? We own the Deec. Had our land surveyed and pay the taxes. Our family has been threatened by the bullies. My wife, an RN, arrested on our own property, for letting the sap they are collecting off our land on the ground. We paid over $30,000 dollars thus far defending ourselves against Mr. Roach. Mr. Roavhrepesents the bullies related to Wyoming County government politics. My wife arrested again with handcuffs a year later for being near our property. The bully had the court put an order of protection on her, along with the fine we had to pay the bully. The bully’s threats and damage to our property, are ignored by the sheriffs of Wyoming County. Our hardworking family did not deserve this. Mr. Roach says don’t call him for resolution as he hung up on us 3 times and threaten us again. The second arrest, I was in the car with my wife seeing the bullies on our property. The bully had the right to have her arrested across the street in our car with me. THIS is justice in our country. Please note anyone’s deeded land can be taken by government by making it a civil matter to hide behind, and of course a lawyer like Mr. Roach who can cause your family hardship because he can.
“We own our LAND”…not the Deer .Our land is posted land but bullys. are allowed to ignore the tree signs, and throw other signs in the woods. They hunt on our land without permission.
A Resolution?? Re-write For 8 years we have had squatters on our property represented by Mr. Roach. Where is our resolution?? We own the Deed. Had our land surveyed and pay the taxes. Our family has been threatened by bullies. My wife, an RN, was arrested on our own property, for letting the sap they are collecting off our land on the ground. We paid over $30,000 dollars thus far defending ourselves against Mr. Roach. Mr. Roach represents the bullies related to Wyoming County government politics. My wife was arrested again with handcuffs a year later for being near our property. The bully had the court put an order of protection on her, along with the fine we had to pay the bully. The bully’s threats and damage to our property are ignored by the sheriffs of Wyoming County. Our hardworking family did not deserve this. Mr. Roach says don’t call him for resolution as he hung up on us 3 times and threatened us again. The second arrest, I was in the car with my wife seeing the bullies on our property. The bully had the right to have her arrested across the street in our car with me. THIS is justice in Wyoming County, NY. Please note anyone’s deeded land can be taken by the government, by making it a civil matter to hide behind. A lawyer like Mr. Roach can cause your family hardship because he can.