GENESEE COUNTY/Stafford seeking $2,285.76 from Pontillo for missing court-ordered repair deadline

BY MIKE PETTINELLA
For Video News Service

A lawyer representing the Town of Stafford on Thursday said that James Pontillo, owner of the former Stafford Trading Post at the corner of Routes 5 and 237, must pay a fine of $2,285.76 prior to the town issuing a certificate of completion of court-ordered repairs.

David Roach, attorney with DiMatteo Roach & Kelly of Warsaw, told Video News Service that Stafford Code Enforcement Officer Gene Sinclair determined that Pontillo missed the Sept. 15 deadline to complete a list of 18 items by 16 days.

The court order, which was signed on Feb. 11 by Genesee County Supreme Court Judge Diane Y. Devlin, specifies that Pontillo would be subject to fines of $1,000 per week – or $142.86 per day for every day after the deadline.

Roach said the years-long dispute between the town and Pontillo has boiled down to payment of the fine to receive the certificate of completion as spelled out by the court order and the building permit.

“It is a stipulated order; an agreement of two parties by order of the court,” Roach said. “Mr. Pontillo has been told of the amount due.”

The attorney added that he found out that Pontillo did not start the work until late summer and also heard that Pontillo does not intend to pay the fine, something that Pontillo himself indicated to this news outlet earlier this week.

“He’s said he’s not going to pay,” Roach said. “You sign something, give your word and then blame everybody else under the sun except yourself.”

Pontillo has repeatedly claimed that he was prevented from completing siding and other work on time because employees and patrons at the neighboring Shell’s Post store were parking very close to his property line.

He said he rented a lift for a week but was unable to use it because of the vehicles on the west side of the structure. Finally, he said, he completed the siding by putting the lift on the Shell’s parking lot “and even then, employees were parking on the line.”

Pontillo said he reported several cases of vandalism to authorities, ultimately prompting him to install cameras around the building.

“I’m prepared to go back to court to explain why I wasn’t compliant in time, and I will subpoena people,” Pontillo said, adding that he has compiled video evidence supporting his claims.

Pontillo said he had asked Sinclair four or five times to perform a preliminary inspection to go over the list but was turned down. He said that Sinclair eventually approved the work “verbally” while also informing him of the fine.

Roach explained that the certificate of completion is not the same as a certificate of occupancy.

“That (certificate of occupancy) is still prohibited,” he said. “Mr. Pontillo would need a separate building permit to work inside. Our agreement was to bring the external portion in compliance with the uniform code as long as the building was not at risk of collapsing and looks presentable on the outside.”

Pontillo contends that the town board should consider what he calls “adolescent behavior” of parking vehicles next to his property and said he plans to state his case at the board’s Oct. 13 meeting.

He said he recently was able to talk with Tom and Todd Englerth, owners of Shell’s Post, but not until after the deadline had passed.

“They approached me on two separate occasions and said they want to work with us and have good relations,” Pontillo said. “Why did they wait so long? I think that if they’re serious (about patching things up), they should speak at the meeting and end this.”

As previously reported, the “punch list” identified by the Town of Stafford — and then looked into by architect Matthew Hume on behalf of Pontillo – are as follows:

— Replace 11 support columns in the basement and certify the building is structurally sound. (Hume, in a separate letter to Pontillo, stated that he conducted a visual inspection of the columns and that “these wood columns and their footings are of sufficient size and integrity to support the current loads from the first floor, and they are not in any immediate danger of falling).
— Replace exterior siding with long-term weather protection.
— Replace rotted exterior wood boards.
— Replace missing wood shingles and trim; scrape and paint all exterior walls.
— Properly replace the exterior landing for the first-floor door on the north side of the building.
— Permanently fix or wall off second story egress door and refurbish or replace the first-floor doors on the north side of the building.
— Install missing soffits.
— Fix leaks in roof.
— Replace boarded and broken windows.
— Remove electric meter box on east side of building; attach new meter box to west side of building.
— Fill in hole at the bottom of the foundation wall.
— Remove broken concrete on north side of the building.
— Fix foundation walls.
— Restore the rusty awning.
— Repair steps on west end of front platform.
— Apply protective sealant to the wood deck.
— Repair hole in upper area of south side of building.
— Repair and install fencing or remove the same on the west side of the building.

4 Comments:

  1. What is it with Stafford – Leave the man alone. With ALL the GARBAGE you have put him through ge is doing a Great job. Just GARBAGE

  2. Jeffrey Van Buren

    He should now apply for tax incentives and low interest loans from the GCEDC. Maybe that’s just for out of the area companies.

  3. Looks great Jim keep up the good work.

  4. Pingback: GENESEE COUNTY/Stafford Town Board to consult attorney regarding Pontillo’s request to waive fine – Video News Service

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *