
(File photo)
BY MIKE PETTINELLA
For Video News Service
Barring a negotiated settlement, which seems doubtful at this point, Town of Stafford officials and property owner James Pontillo are heading back to court.
David Roach, attorney with DiMatteo Roach & Kelly of Warsaw, on Oct. 16 filed a notice of motion in Genesee County Supreme Court on behalf of the town.
The motion seeks a judgment of $2,285.76 in fines against Pontillo for his failure to meet a court-ordered deadline for repairs at the former Stafford Trading Post building at 6177 Main St. Rd.
The court date in front of Judge Diane Devlin is scheduled for 10 a.m. Nov. 20 at the Genesee County Court Facility.
Pontillo is contending that extenuating circumstances out of his control prevented him from finishing a list of 18 repairs and renovations by the Sept. 16 deadline.
The town argues that the stipulated order dated Feb. 11 between the two parties, per an affidavit signed by Code Enforcement Officer Gene Sinclair, “does not provide any exceptions or circumstances to excuse failure to comply with the deadline.”
The stipulated order states that Pontillo would be subject to a fine of $1,000 per week – or $142.86 per day – for non-compliance. Apparently, both parties agreed that the work was completed on Oct. 2 – 16 days after the deadline.
As a result, the town has levied the fine of $2,285.76 and also is seeking 9 percent interest from that Sept. 16 date.

Pontillo addressed town councilmen at its Oct. 13 meeting, asking them to rescind the fine and to put the matter behind them. Board members offered no concessions, instead stating that it could set a precedent and that they would be consulting their attorney, David Roach. (File photo/Mike Pettinella)
It should be noted that Sinclair signed his affidavit, which was notarized by Town Clerk Barbara Radley, on Oct. 9 – four days before the board meeting.
“They already knew the position that they were taking and they kind of led us to believe that we’re going to discuss it,” Pontillo said on Tuesday morning. “They already had decided that they were going to take further action.”
ROACH: PAY THE FINE AND END IT
Roach, contacted on Monday afternoon, used a football analogy to define the status of the what has been a years-long dispute over the condition of the historic structure.
“We’re already in the end zone and he just needs to pay the fine,” he said. “Everything else that the town had sought and that the parties had agreed upon has been done. He just needs to pay the fine, which he had agreed upon in the order.”
Roach said it isn’t a matter of relitigating the issue of how many building code violations Pontillo had incurred.
“This is just purely the issue of how many days did he fail to complete the agreed upon, slash court-ordered work past September 15th,” he added.
Roach said that Pontillo’s failure to meet the deadline can be attributed in large part to not starting the work until the summer – well beyond the February date of the original court order.
“I don’t know when he started the work; I can’t quote the exact date. What I can’t tell you is that there were months where he did not perform any work and work could have been performed. So, I think the circumstance that led to this is purely his procrastination.”
Pontillo has stated that the winter months prevented him from siding the building, plus he had projects at other properties that he owned that needed immediate attention.
Roach said that Pontillo could have been fined up to $1,000 per day for code violations cited by the town prior to the current fine for missing the deadline.
“So, the town was extremely lenient with Mr. Pontillo in that regard,” he said. “The town was more interested in seeing the work actually performed than seeing a huge fine.”
PONTILLO: SHOE’S ON THE OTHER FOOT
Pontillo brought up a $2,500 fine that he ended up paying several years ago over the fence on the west side of the property – something that he said was thrown out in Supreme Court and should have been returned to him.
“When they were to return my funds at that time, I was told by the board to take us to court,” he said. “The only reason I did not was it would have cost me more (in attorney fees) to do so. Now that the shoe is on the other foot, the town board has no problem taking me to court for a fine.”
Roach, when asked if he agreed that a precedent would be set by the town’s waiving the fine for missing the deadline, said, “I don’t want to comment on whether it’s a precedent.”
“That’s a legal question that I’d rather … doesn’t pertain to the situation here, which again, I think is simple: You agreed to pay the fine and if you weren’t done by September 15th, you procrastinated,” he said.
Asked if he thought Judge Devlin would consider circumstances cited by Pontillo – people parking their vehicles on his property line to prevent him from working and vandalism, for example – Roach then explained the legal process.
“I can say that any time there is an agreement – and let’s take it out of the context of the court order – because it’s a stipulated order, basically the parties agreed to be court ordered,” he said. “If you have just an agreement and that agreement is contained in a written instrument, such as a contract, and there’s a dispute between the parties as to what the agreement requires, then the court’s first obligation is to, first and foremost, determine the intent of the parties.
“The first step toward that end is to read the plain language of the agreement and to enforce the plain language of the agreement – regardless of what anything else says. But if there’s an ambiguity in the agreement, then the court can look at what’s called parol evidence, which is something outside the four corners of the agreement that offers some sort of explanation as to what was intended in the ambiguity.”
Roach said in this case, the agreement is ordered by the court “to do certain things and in this agreement, it is very clear what the deadline is, and the agreement doesn’t provide for any exceptions to that deadline.”
Pontillo called out the town board for a lack of transparency.
“The board is not transparent, is very vindictive and litigious,” he said. “They just go after people. If they don’t like you, they go after you.”
The town needs to get over itself and wave the fine as a show of good faith. People connected to the “town” have done everything in their power to Cause this man problems with this building. This is some seriously petty town board BS. Hopefully we can vote out the offenders and make this town a place that people want to live and grow, rather than keep it a 1840’s farming community run by several old men who think they own and control everyone.
I bet you Mr Roach is making more than $2200 to file the motion
What is considered a vindictive County, is living in Wyoming County. Wyoming County will go after anyone they can. They will change legal paperwork to suit their agenda, and put you in the hot seat. There is no transparentcy in law enforcement. David Roche was a poor choice of the defense for this case. He represents another client who violates our State and Country Laws. Our good, hardworking family gets dogged by Wyoming County when they want something. In our case, it is our land squatted on for their friends related to local government. How do you fight a fair case when you have a legal Deed, had your land surveyed, pay the taxes and one of Wyoming County friends want your land for liquid gold. (maple syrup) The land has been in our family since the 1900’s. Great grandpa days. 30,000 dollars in legal fees and 8 years for your day in court to get them off your property. You can not. The Wyoming County judge is related to the squatters and Roche is defending them. THAT is what Wyoming County Law is all about. The land owner gets arrested after significant damage to their land, theft of property, threats to health and welfare. A land owner who has contributed to community by being a Registered Nurse for 45 years, a Military Veteran, work with Homeland Security and Justice Department but can not fight the old men who control Wyoming County. It a real sad for people how backwoods justice works. New York State is ready to revolk your working Nurse’s licence for the greed of money and lies. Keep hoping justice will one day prevail, but seeing how our law system works, money prevails over life. How many men sit in jail having been set-up for the workings of “their” law system? From the containation of our family farm well, to this land steal, if we don’t continue to shell out for justice, then what kind of a future does honest man have? Shame
That town board are a heaping pile of stank as* garbage.
The state has a obligation in this and so doze the federal government. GET them involved
They pass the buck. No ones job.