Derek R. Spillman, 41, of Niagara Falls, NY, was arrested following a 911 hang up investigation that
occurred in the Town of Genesee Falls.
On 03/15/2026, following an investigation, it was determined that Spillman was allegedly inside his vehicle with his wife, Stephanie Spillman when it was discovered that a complete stay away order of protection was in place.
Spillman was arrested and charged with for criminal contempt in the 2nd degree.
He was arraigned in the Town of Genesee Falls court and was remanded to the
Wyoming County Jail on a $10,000 cash bail and $20,000 bond.
Spillman will answer to the charges on 03/25/2026 in the Town of Genesee Falls Court.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
On March 11th, 2026 the Wyoming County Sheriff’s Office responded to a one-car motor vehicle
accident on Route 19A in the Town of Gainesville.
Following an investigation, deputies determined that a Nissan, operated by Daniel McCart,
21 of Castile, NY, left the eastbound lane of the roadway and entered a ditch.
During the investigation, deputies observed alleged signs of intoxication.
McCart submitted to roadside field sobriety tests and was subsequently arrested and charged with Driving While Intoxicated.
McCart was taken into custody and transported to the Wyoming County Sheriff’s Office for
processing, where he also submitted to a chemical test. McCart was released with appearance tickets and is scheduled to appear at a later date in Town of Gainesville Court to answer the charges
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Teresa Guerrero, 27, of Olean, NY, was arrested following a traffic stop on Route 39 in the
Town of Castile on March 11, 2026.
Guerrero was observed to be operating a motor vehicle at high speeds.
After a roadside interview, it was discovered that Guerrero had been operating the vehicle with a
suspended New York State driver’s license.
Guerrero was charged with aggravated unlicensed operation 3rd degree She was issued an appearance ticket and was advised to return to the Town of Castile Court at a later date.
____________________________________________________________________________________________
On March 14, 2026, at approximately 7:41pm, deputies were requested to E. Koy Road in the
Town of Genesee Falls for a possible roadside domestic incident.
Upon arrival, the driver, who was identified as Stephanie Balbo-Spillman, 40 of Niagara Falls, NY, was allegedly exhibiting signs of impairment.
Deputies administered field sobriety testing roadside and Balbo-Spillman was subsequently arrested for
operating a motor vehicle under the influence of drugs.
Balbo-Spillman was transported to Warsaw Police Department for processing at which point Balbo-Spillman became combative kicking the deputy and spitting multiple times in the deputy’s face.
Balbo-Spillman was ultimately charged with harassment 2nd degree, obstructing governmental
administration 2nd degree, aggravated unlicensed operation of a motor vehicle 3rd degree and
operating a motor vehicle impaired by drugs.
Balbo-Spillman was issued appearance tickets and is to appear at Genesee Falls Court and Warsaw Court at a later date.