JOINT PRESS RELEASE – April 1st, 2026
On December 17, 2024, the Medina Police Department and Medina Fire Department responded to a structure fire at 207 Bates Road. A mother and her son were forced to evacuate the residence as a result of the fire.
A subsequent investigation determined that the fire had been intentionally set.
Through a coordinated investigative effort, Zachary Natale was identified as the responsible party and was arrested and charged with Arson in the Second Degree, Burglary in the Second Degree, and Reckless Endangerment in the First Degree.
On April 1, 2026, the Honorable Judge Sanford Church sentenced Natale to 13 years in New York State Prison, followed by 5 years of post-release supervision.
This case is the result of a collaborative effort between multiple agencies. The Medina Police Department and Medina Fire Department would like to recognize the following individuals and agencies for their assistance:
•Medina Police Department: Officers Meredith, McManus, and Holtz
•Medina Fire Department Fire Investigation Unit: Investigators Cooley, Crooks, and Seefeldt
•Orleans County Sheriff’s Office: Investigator Marsciell
•Orleans County Emergency Management: Director Niederhofer, Deputy Director Buffin, Investigators David Clary and Cole Hardenbrook
•Erie County Crime Lab
•Erie County Sheriff’s Office: Detective Scott Kuhlney and K9 Clipper
•Orleans County District Attorney’s Office, including District Attorney Susan Howard and staff
The Medina Police Department and Medina Fire Department remain committed to protecting the community and holding those responsible for violent and dangerous acts accountable.