Isaac W. Hilton, 20, of Altmar, NY, is facing numerous charges stemming from incidents that occurred
on March 28th and March 29th.
On March 28th, the Wyoming County Sheriff’s Office received a complaint of a male subject
stealing merchandise from Walmart on Route 19 in the Town of Warsaw. The subject
would later return to the store and attempt to return the stolen items. This occurred multiple
times throughout the day. The subject was identified as Isaac Hilton, and charges were pending
at that time.
Hilton was later taken into custody by the Warsaw Police Department in connection with a
domestic incident that had occurred the previous night. Following his arrest and arraignment,
Hilton was turned over to the Sheriff’s Office and processed on two counts of Petit Larceny. He
was issued appearance tickets returnable to the Town of Warsaw Court on May 4th.
On March 29th, at approximately 6:00 a.m., the Wyoming County Sheriff’s Office responded to
a one-car motor vehicle accident on Route 20A in the Town of Perry. Hilton was identified
as the sole occupant and driver of the vehicle. Following a roadside investigation, Hilton was
placed under arrest and charged with Driving While Ability Impaired by Drugs (DWAI-Drugs). Hilton was
transported to WCCH, where he provided a blood sample and underwent a drug influence evaluation.
Following the evaluation, Hilton was determined to allegdly be under the influence of drugs
and unable to operate a motor vehicle safely.
Hilton was issued appearance tickets returnable to the Town of Perry Court for April 8th on the
charges of DWAI-Drugs, moving from lane unsafely, and failure to keep right.
Eddy’s Collision assisted at the scene
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
Michael P. Brown Jr., 37, of Java, NY, was arrested following an investigation after a female
subject had contacted the Wyoming County Sheriff’s Office and explained that she and Brown
had been involved in an alleged domestic incident that had allegedly become physical.
The victim described the argument and stated that she was allegedly struck in the face by Brown with an
open hand during the argument. Deputies collected statements from the victim and a witness to
the incident.
Deputies traveled to an address on Brookside Drive in the Town of Java and met
with Brown. He explained how the argument started and admitted to hitting his girlfriend.
Brown was arrested and charged with Assault in the 3rd degree and Aggravated Family Offense.
Brown was arraigned on the charges, and appeared in the Town of Java Court on
04/08/2026
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Jade A. Duffin, 19, of Perry, NY, was arrested following a traffic accident on Sanford Road in the
Town of Castile on April 5th, 2026.
Duffin was traveling southbound on Sanford Road when she failed to navigate a curve and went off the eastern shoulder of the roadway sideways, causing her vehicle to roll over. Duffin’s vehicle rolled into a parked farm tractor and parked farm truck causing damage.
Duffin was assessed medically by the Town of Perry Ambulance, and was interviewed by
deputies on scene. While speaking with Duffin, deputies observed alleged signs of impairment.
Duffin was asked to perform field sobriety tests, which she performed poorly. Duffin was taken to the
Wyoming County Sheriff’s Office for a chemical breath test. She was arrested and charged
with Driving While Intoxicated (DWI), Aggravated DWI .18 of 1% or more Alcohol Content,
Aggravated Unlicensed Operation, Operation of a Motor Vehicle Without Inspection, and
Failure to Keep Right.
Duffin was issued an appearance ticket on all charges and was advised to return to the Town of
Castile Court at a later date
____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Elizabeth A. Fox, 41, of Warsaw, NY, was arrested following a report of shoplifting at Walmart
in the Town of Warsaw on April 9th, 2026.
It is alleged that Fox stole approximately $224 worth of merchandise. Fox was processed at the
Wyoming County Sheriff’s Office and charged with Petit Larceny.
Fox was issued an appearance ticket and is scheduled to appear in the Town of Warsaw Court on
April 20, 2026
______________________________________________________________________________________________________
Following a traffic stop for an inspection violation on South Main Street in the Village of
Warsaw on April 8th, 2026, Ian Smith, 21, of Fillmore, NY, was arrested and charged with Aggravated Unlicensed Operation in the 2nd Degree.
An investigation revealed that Smith had seven active suspensions on his driver’s license on three
separate dates.
Smith was processed at the scene and issued an appearance ticket. He is scheduled to appear in
the Village of Warsaw Court at a later date to answer the charge
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Justin P. Grimm, 32, of Buffalo, NY, was charged following a traffic stop on Route 20A in the
Village of Warsaw on April 9th, 2026. Grimm was found to be operating a vehicle with a suspended registration for a violation of NYS tolls. Grimm was also found to have a suspended license due to failure to pay driver’s responsibility assessment.
Grimm was charged with operation with suspended registration and aggravated unlicensed
operation 3rd degree. Grimm is to appear in Village Court at a later date.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
An 18-year-old from Pike, NY, is facing charges following a shoplifting incident at Wal-Mart in the
Town of Warsaw.
On March 29th, the individual was found to have stolen approximately $250 worth of merchandise from the store while enlisting the assistance of a 15-year-old.
The subject was charged with petit larceny, endangering the welfare of a child, and fifth-degree
conspiracy (for using someone under the age of 16 to commit a crime).
An appearance ticket was issued for all charges, returnable to Town Court at a later date.