
Protesters converged upon the GCEDC board meeting on Thursday afternoon on Med-Tech Drive. Photos by Mike Pettinella/For Video News Service.
BY MIKE PETTINELLA
For Video News Service
New York State legislators on Thursday night passed a bill that would place a one-year moratorium on the permitting of data centers, a move that would become law should Gov. Kathy Hochul elect to sign off on it.
Hours earlier, directors of the Genesee County Economic Development Center – with about 15 people holding signs in protest joining them in the board room on Med-Tech Drive, approved three resolutions related to the proposed $19.46 billion, 2.2-million-square-foot STREAM U.S. Data Centers’ structure at Western New York Science & Technology Advanced Manufacturing Park.
One of the measures dealt with payment for environmental and noise study reviews and the other two covered power substation work at the 1,250-acre campus in the Town of Alabama:
— A recommendation from the STAMP committee to pay $5,000 to CC Environment & Planning and $750,000 to Philips Lytle for their assistance in the evaluation of the 500-megawatt data center, with costs to be reimbursed by STREAM U.S.
“Payment is for what already has been done and what we anticipate is left to finish,” GCEDC President/CEO Mark Masse said. “So, that should get us through documentation.”
— Transferring $1 million as part of an agreement with the New York Power Authority to reimburse the NYPA for its review and design of the substation at STAMP.
— Entering into a $4.3 million contract with Rochester Gas & Electric Corporation for high-level engineering, construction requirements and estimated costs in connection with the existing RG&E substation 255 electric facility.

Masse then informed the board of a June 4th letter from Dennis Elsenbeck of Philips Lytle LLC that addressed public comments about the data center’s energy usage, STAMP’s power grid capacity and a potential increase in residential electric rates.
Elsenbeck, a former employee of National Grid, wrote that STAMP has the capacity to support the 500-megawatt data center, citing the New York Independent System Operator’s determination that the site can handle a total of 600 megawatts of annual electrical demand.
The letter indicates that STAMP’s substation will draw power from the existing NYPA 345KV transmission line that originates at the Robert Moses Plant, adding that the “vast majority of new generation planned to be installed in Western New York tends to be renewable in nature.”
Elsenbeck wrote that the data center could positively impact consumer electric rates.
“A data center’s contributions to the fixed climate-related costs of achieving the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act objectives could actually help relieve the financial burden on all electric ratepayers because those costs can be recovered through the line-item subsidies on a data center’s relatively high electric bill totals,” he wrote.
In his conclusion, Elsenbeck wrote that the data center could drive substantial county and state sales tax revenues, something that the GCEDC has articulated in previous reports.
As directors were leaving the board room, one of the protesters, Sandy Steele of Batavia, spoke out, asking directors if they would be profiting from the siting of the data center. Masse replied that it was an all-volunteer board.
Steele then said she was talking about compensation from stock holdings, prompting Masse say that all had to file financial disclosure forms.
A brief back-and-forth ensued with Steele accusing Masse of lying about the Town of Alabama’s vote to pass the measure and Masse responding that the town board did vote in 2012 before being cut off by Steele.
Director Craig Yunker did stay in the room for several minutes afterwards, listening to some of the protesters’ concerns.
Such an important decision to be made affecting such a wide margin of people and the best positive things he can say are labeled as, could do this or could do that? Not exactly the outcome reassurance people would expect or accept!