BATAVIA/ZBA approves variances for signage and a landscape buffer at the new Taco Bell site on Montclair Avenue, residents speak out against the project

Stephanie Albright, Senior Civil Engineer at APD Engineering & Architecture goes over the site plan with ZBA members on Thursday, October 22nd.

At the City of Batavia ZBA meeting Thursday evening, Mike McCracken/Hospitality Syracuse/Taco Bell requested a reduction in width of the required landscape buffer from 10 ft to 5 ft adjacent to the eastern lot line, and approval to deviate from the sign code requirements of the Batavia Municipal Code.

During the meeting, Taco Bell agreed to keep their main sign to code at 15 feet. The proposed sign was 15.58.

The ZBA approved the other variance requests after going through an uncoordinated State Environmental Quality Review (SEQR) process for each requested variance.

  1. BMC 190-39 B (1)(b) Parking located in front of principal buildings located within the C-2 district
    shall be setback from the front lot line by a landscaped buffer at least 10′ in width. The applicant is
    proposing a 5′ buffer adjacent to the eastern lot line.
  2. BMC 190-43M Pole signs located within the C-2 district may be a maximum of 40 sq.’ in area.
    53.4 sq.’ is proposed.
  3. BMC 190-43 T Pole signs may have a maximum vertical height under the sign of 15′ above grade.
    The applicant is proposing 15.58′
  4. BMC 190-43 M Only one wall sign per establishment, per building wall visible from a public right
    of way is allowed. 2 wall signs are proposed on the southern elevation, and 2 on the western
    elevation.
  5. BMC 190-43 I (6) On-site directional signs are permitted to be a maximum of 4′ in height. Two
    “Mobile Pick-up” directional signs are proposed at 6′ in height.

Earlier this month, County Planners disapproved the project. The area of 244-248 W. Main Street, the former Timebuyer location is zoned a General Commercial (C-2) District.

In their planning board referral, county planners said that given the proposed restaurant’s location adjacent to a residential neighborhood and that the overall sign package substantially deviates from the City’s sign regulations, the granting of so many variances may pose significant county wide or inter-community impacts.

At the Tuesday October 20th City of Batavia Planning and Development Committee meeting, the project was approved after a traffic study was completed.

CITY OF BATAVIA/Planning & Development Committee approves Taco Bell project after traffic study completed, next hurdle, the ZBA on Thursday/Baskin Livestock Feed Processing Facility project tabled until the November 5th meeting – Video News Service

Montclair Avenue residents spoke against the new Taco Bell at the ZBA meeting on Thursday. Some say they plan to move from the neighborhood; others say the traffic study does not show a full picture as it was completed in the summer and not during the school year, when school buses stop at the intersection to pick up and drop off students each day.

Several residents of Montclair Avenue affected by the new Taco Bell spoke during the public hearing portion of the City ZBA meeting on Thursday evening, after they say they were not advised of the Planning and Development Committee meeting on Tuesday night, where the project was approved.

Charlie Boyd, a resident of Montclair Avenue, thanked the ZBA Board for advertising the meeting and agenda with all the documents before the meeting and for allowing residents to be heard. Boyd says residents say they did not have a voice during Tuesday’s meeting. Boyd told the ZBA members that the variance requests were not minor exemptions but significant and he feels they should be rejected.

“I think when they’re saying in their statement that it doesn’t affect the neighborhood adversely, I think that is…lets see…what would Colonel Potter say…..horse something or other, going back to M*A*S*h sorry. For them to say, we can’t do anything else, remember they chose that piece of land. There are places like the old Pizza Hut, that would be great, it’s already a strip mall. They’re taking the strip mall approach where you only have to worry about businesses on either side and putting it in a residential neighborhood,” says Boyd.

The owner of the property at 244-248 West Main Street, Chan Patel, tells the ZBA that the project should move forward at Montclair Avenue and West Main Street saying the City needs to be business friendly

“It is a commercial zone so there is going to be noise. Before I came to the planning board and suggested a convenience store, anything that will come in there will be noise. The city has to be business friendly. Another thing about the landscaping buffer, there is no landscaping right now, it’s a good thing, they will make an improvement,” says Chan Patel, property owner.

(File photo)

Kathy Saile has lived on Montclair Avenue for 33 years. She is concerned that the traffic study was completed in the summer and not during the school year when students are waiting to be picked up and dropped off at the corner of Montclair and West Main each day. She also is concerned about people using Montclair as a cut through to Oak Street as it is difficult to make a left onto West Main from Montclair. Saile says some days she waits a long time to turn left onto West Main.

“We already have the pot store; we don’t really need more traffic with Taco Bell. People go get their pot then they’ll get their Taco Bell, and our street is going to be crazy. They’ll use this as a cut through to get back to Oak Street. None of us bought our houses here to be in a commercial district and it would be sad to see this happen to our street and our neighborhood,” says Saile.

Neighbor Brian Demko lives right next door to the property and says he will have no place to push his snow and will now have to deal with light and noise. Taco Bell opens at 7AM and closes at 1AM. On Friday and Saturdays, they are open until 2AM. He says his wife sometimes has to use a different street to get home from work because at 5PM you cannot make a turn onto Montclair.

“Taco Bell is known to be open until 1AM, I don’t need those lights in my living room, my bedroom and the traffic keeping us awake. The other problem is they want to build a giant fence. I ‘ll have no place to put snow. I have problems with snow removal now because I have no lawn. I’ve had cops come to my house because I’ve thrown snow in the street. It’s just a terrible location. There are kids, the noise, the traffic, it’s just not a good place to have a business that’s open until one o’clock in the morning,” says Demko.

Sean Henderson has lived on Montclair Avenue for 9 years; he is concerned about the reduction of the landscape buffer from 10 to 5 feet.

“I’m concerned about the reduced landscape buffer along Montclair Avenue, yeah its 5 feet, but that’s a 50% reduction. If a restaurant says we serve 100 % beef and we found out later that they serve 50% beef, I think we’d be upset. It was reported that the application states that the bypass lane was preferred even though it would require a landscaping variance. If a different lay out or the removal of that lane could allow the required 10 foot buffer, I ask the board to explain why the neighborhood should accept a reduced buffer to preserve the preferred design, This is not just a question of whether a restaurant can operate on this property, it’s whether the applicant has demonstrated that each requested exception is justified and whether the benefits to the applicant outweigh the potential detriment to nearby residents.”

After closing the public hearing portion of the meeting, the ZBA went through the SEQR process for each requested variance. During that portion of the meeting, one resident, Brian Demko, questioned the process saying the board was skipping over a safety question. Demko was told by Code Enforcement officer Doug Randall that the public comment portion of the meeting was closed.

“Then have me removed” he said.

Less than two minutes later, Demko again had an outburst when the board continued to go through the SEQR process discussing the landscape buffer and if there would be an undesirable change to the area, board members responded no.

“What do you mean no, you don’t even live there, you can’t say no.” Demko was again warned that the public comment period was closed.

“I don’t care,” he shouted. You’re lying to us. You’re taking money from Taco Bell and you’re lying to us and were all sitting right here.”

As the meeting was closing, Demko then stood up and shouted, “You guys are pathetic, pathetic guys! You hid the meeting on Tuesday from us and now we can’t vote against the Taco Bell. This is a pathetic show and your just taking money from corporations, F-ck you guys! Demco then stormed out of chambers.

Previously:

https://videonewsservice.net/index.php/2026/08/18/genesee-county-city-pdc-tables-taco-bell-matter-pending-review-of-traffic-study/

https://videonewsservice.net/index.php/2026/07/21/batavia-taco-bell-changes-their-plans-a-bit-during-a-concept-review-at-the-planning-and-development-committee-meeting/

https://videonewsservice.net/index.php/2026/07/17/batavia-taco-bell-looking-to-move-to-west-main-and-montclair-avenue/

One Comment:

  1. I don’t know what the City is doing, but they obviously have not thought this through.

    Any sort of business there will add traffic to an already busy area with the light on N Lyon, and any egress to Main Street will force customers to turn right onto Main, then turn right again at the light adding further traffic to N Lyon, especially when the kids are out playing or coming home from being dropped off by the school bus. Even with any ingress or egress onto Montclair, traffic will be backed up further on Lacrosse going in either direction towards Oak or N Lyon, thereby causing more issues especially during rush hours.

    Any traffic study done must have been 3 AM in the morning as it most likely doesn’t consider the school children being dropped off there or at the corner where the light is, nor does it seem to consider the rush hour traffic, including the multitde of semi-trucks coming from the major intersection at Oak and Main.

    I’m all for businesses in this city but not at the expense of common sense. This needs to be scrapped.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *